The Struggle to Keep Gen Z and Millennials Engaged in Giving
September 4, 2025
byGiveable AI Research
For generations, church giving was steady and predictable. But times have changed. Today, pastors and church leaders are finding it increasingly difficult to keep younger generations - Millennials and Gen Z - engaged in generosity. These groups aren’t against giving. In fact, they are some of the most socially conscious and mission-driven generations we’ve ever seen. The struggle lies in how they want to give, why they give, and the level of transparency and impact they expect in return.
This isn’t a story of lost generosity - it’s a story of shifting values. To engage younger donors, churches must rethink how they communicate, how they build trust, and how they make giving meaningful.
Why Younger Generations View Giving Differently
Millennials and Gen Z were raised in an entirely different cultural context compared to their parents and grandparents. They’re digital natives, globally connected, and deeply aware of issues like poverty, climate change, and social justice. Their giving is often:
- Cause-Driven: They prefer giving to specific missions or projects rather than general funds.
- Digital-First: They rarely carry cash and expect mobile-friendly giving options.
- Impact-Oriented: They want to see tangible results from their generosity.
- Value-Driven: They give to organizations that align with their personal values.
If the church doesn’t provide these pathways, many will disengage - even if they love the community.
The Trust Gap Between Churches and Young Donors
A central challenge is trust. Millennials and Gen Z are more skeptical of institutions than older generations. They want to know that funds are managed transparently and used responsibly.
When financial practices seem vague or closed-off, younger donors pull back. But when churches openly communicate how money is used - and connect it to real-world stories - trust grows, and engagement follows.
Communication That Resonates
Church bulletins and annual budget reports aren’t enough anymore. Younger givers are accustomed to receiving updates in real time. They want:
- Stories shared on social media.
- Short videos that highlight community impact.
- Monthly updates that show progress toward goals.
Instead of focusing solely on “how much was raised,” churches should focus on what those funds accomplished.
Blocks: Practical Ways to Engage Younger Donors
Block 1: Storytelling Over Numbers
Instead of saying, “We raised $20,000 for outreach,” share a video testimony from a family who received support through that outreach program.
Block 2: Digital Giving Options
Offer easy tools like text-to-give, QR codes, and mobile apps. For Gen Z, giving must be as seamless as Venmo or PayPal.
Block 3: Participation Opportunities
Engagement isn’t just about money. Invite younger members to volunteer, lead projects, or contribute ideas. When they feel invested in the mission, financial support follows.
Why General Funds Don’t Inspire Younger Generosity
A major reason younger donors struggle with giving is that many churches rely heavily on “general funds.” While these are necessary for keeping the church running, they don’t spark inspiration.
Millennials and Gen Z are more motivated by specificity - knowing exactly what their money supports. Churches that create campaigns for youth programs, mission trips, community outreach, or building improvements often see better engagement from these groups.
Technology as a Bridge, Not a Barrier
Technology is not just a convenience for younger donors - it’s a trust signal. A church without mobile giving options may unintentionally communicate that it’s behind the times. Digital tools can:
- Allow for recurring giving with one click.
- Provide instant receipts and tax documentation.
- Display progress toward specific campaigns.
- Reinforce transparency with donor dashboards.
In short, the more accessible and visible the giving process, the more engaged younger members become.
The Role of Purpose and Mission Alignment
Both Millennials and Gen Z want to know their giving is part of something bigger. They aren’t content with maintaining the status quo - they want to contribute to causes that change lives.
Churches that clearly articulate their mission and connect it to local and global impact have a stronger chance of engaging these generations. For example:
- A youth group raising money for mental health resources in schools.
- A missions fund supporting refugees.
- A local initiative providing food for low-income families.
Specific causes align with their desire for purposeful, values-driven generosity.
Avoiding the Guilt-Based Approach
Older stewardship campaigns often leaned on obligation or guilt: “Tithing is your duty.” For Millennials and Gen Z, that approach backfires. They respond not to guilt, but to vision and opportunity.
When churches shift the message from “You should give” to “Here’s the impact you can make”, generosity becomes an invitation rather than a burden.
Re-Imagining Engagement Beyond Money
Finally, churches must remember that giving isn’t just financial. Younger generations often start by investing time, creativity, and energy before money follows. Churches that provide avenues for younger members to serve, lead, and participate are planting seeds that later grow into financial generosity.
Conclusion
The struggle to keep Millennials and Gen Z engaged in giving is not about their lack of generosity - it’s about whether churches are willing to adapt. By emphasizing transparency, leveraging digital tools, sharing impact stories, and creating mission-driven opportunities, churches can connect with these younger donors in ways that feel authentic and meaningful.
The future of church giving isn’t declining - it’s evolving. Those who embrace the shift will not only sustain generosity but also build stronger, purpose-driven communities.