For decades, the idea of “10% to the church” was a steady and unquestioned part of Christian life. Generations before us dropped cash into offering plates without hesitation. But today, pastors are finding fewer envelopes and more empty baskets.

It’s not just that people are giving less  -  it’s that the culture around giving has changed. Many churches are realizing that traditional tithing habits don’t carry the same weight they used to.

In this article, we’ll break down seven major cultural shifts that are pulling people away from traditional tithing, and what you can do to adapt without losing sight of your mission.

---

1. Trust in Institutions Has Declined

In the past, the church was one of the most trusted institutions in the community. People believed their tithe was making a direct impact. Today, after decades of scandals and headlines about misuse of funds, public trust in all institutions  -  religious or otherwise  -  has taken a hit.

A Pew Research study found that only 37% of Americans have a high level of trust in religious leaders. That’s not just a statistic  -  it’s a signal that giving now depends on transparency and accountability more than ever.

Show your congregation exactly where their donations go. Annual reports, personal testimonies, and tangible impact stories can rebuild the bridge of trust.

---

2. Giving Is No Longer a Habit Passed Down Automatically

Fifty years ago, parents taught their kids to tithe from their first paycheck. Today’s younger adults weren’t always given that same example. With church attendance itself declining, many never saw regular giving modeled in their home.

Instead, generosity has become more cause-driven and event-based  -  people give to specific needs rather than ongoing commitments.

Shift your message from “tithe because it’s what we do” to “here’s the direct change your giving creates.” Habit takes time to build  -  start by connecting giving to visible impact.

---

3. The Digital Giving Gap

Younger generations manage almost every part of their life online  -  but some churches still treat digital giving as an afterthought. If your donation process involves finding an envelope and a pen, you’re already losing potential givers.

Gen Z and Millennials want to give, but they expect it to be instant, mobile-friendly, and secure. If the church isn’t set up to meet that expectation, giving simply won’t happen.

Make digital giving as frictionless as online shopping. QR codes in bulletins, app-based giving, and automated recurring donations aren’t just trends  -  they’re the new standard.

---

4. Rising Financial Pressure on Families

Inflation, student loans, and housing costs have put enormous pressure on household budgets. Even faithful church members may feel they can’t “afford” to give the way they used to.

This doesn’t necessarily mean they’re unwilling  -  just that they need flexibility. People may be more inclined to give smaller, more frequent gifts rather than a fixed 10%.

Teach that generosity isn’t always about the amount but the heart and consistency. Offer multiple ways to give, including micro-donations and non-monetary contributions like volunteering.

---

5. Competition for Generosity

Nonprofits, online fundraisers, and viral giving campaigns have made generosity a crowded space. People today have endless opportunities to support causes that feel urgent, personal, and visible  -  and they can donate with a single click.

This doesn’t mean churches are less worthy  -  but it does mean the story you tell about your mission matters more than ever.

 Position your church’s giving opportunities as just as urgent and just as personal as any viral campaign. Share local stories, use video, and show immediate results.

---

6. Shifts in Theological Views on Tithing

For some, the concept of a fixed 10% tithe feels outdated or “legalistic.” Many Christians now believe giving should be based on personal conviction rather than a set rule.

While this can feel threatening to church budgets, it also opens the door to deeper discipleship conversations about generosity, stewardship, and gratitude.

Teach the “why” behind giving  -  not just the “how much.” Move from obligation to invitation, showing how generosity reflects God’s heart.

---

7. People Give Where They Feel Belonging

At the heart of every gift is a relationship. If someone feels disconnected from a church’s community, their financial support will likely fade.

Today’s culture is highly relational and experience-driven. People give when they feel seen, valued, and personally invested in the mission  -  not just when they attend on Sunday.

Build belonging before asking for giving. Small groups, personal follow-up, and celebrating milestones in members’ lives can strengthen the relational glue that leads to generosity.

---

The Way Forward

These cultural shifts aren’t a death sentence for church giving  -  they’re an invitation to adapt. Churches that listen, innovate, and lead with transparency can not only survive but thrive in this new giving landscape.

The decline in traditional tithing is real, but so is the opportunity to reimagine how generosity works in your congregation. With the right approach, you can create a culture where giving is joyful, personal, and sustainable.

Want to see how AI can help your church adapt to these changes? Try Giveable for Free