Guidance for Church Leaders: Choosing the Right Consultant for a Capital Campaign

Launching a capital campaign is one of the most ambitious steps a church can take. Whether the goal is building a new sanctuary, expanding facilities, or funding a community project, these campaigns involve significant planning, resources, and commitment. For many leaders, the question arises: Should we bring in outside help?

The short answer is often yes. A seasoned consultant can help churches avoid costly mistakes, provide strategic direction, and ensure that the vision inspires broad support. But knowing what a consultant does, when to hire one, and how to choose the right partner is essential before making the investment.

---

What Does a Capital Campaign Consultant Do?

A consultant is more than an advisor. Their role is to guide leaders through every stage of the fundraising journey. Key responsibilities often include:

• Conducting Feasibility Studies: A consultant assesses whether the campaign goal is realistic and aligned with the church’s current giving capacity.
• Developing Strategy: They design step-by-step plans for engaging members, structuring gifts, and sustaining momentum.
• Training Leaders and Volunteers: Consultants equip pastors, staff, and lay leaders with the tools to communicate vision and inspire generosity.
• Coaching During Campaigns: They provide ongoing support, helping leaders troubleshoot challenges and keep the campaign on track.

Organizations like the Nonprofit Alliance emphasize the importance of professional standards and innovation in fundraising. Consultants bring both technical expertise and the outside perspective needed to move beyond internal blind spots.

---

When Is a Consultant Needed?

Not every campaign requires outside help. Smaller projects, such as funding a van or repairing a roof, may be achievable with strong in-house leadership. However, a consultant becomes valuable when:

• The fundraising goal is larger than the annual budget.
• Leaders feel uncertain about how to structure a campaign.
• The church has little experience with major gift fundraising.
• There is concern about donor fatigue or lack of momentum.

For example, a mid-sized church in Ohio aimed to raise $2 million for a new family life center. Leaders initially tried to manage the campaign themselves but soon realized they lacked the expertise to identify major donors or inspire broader support. After hiring a consultant, the church exceeded its goal by $500,000. The consultant not only guided strategy but also trained leaders to communicate the vision more effectively.

---

How to Find the Right Consultant

Choosing the right partner takes discernment. Here are some steps to consider:

1. Check Experience and References
   Look for consultants who specialize in churches and have a track record of successful campaigns. Resources like Giving Multiplier remind us that evidence-based approaches to giving can amplify results.
2. Assess Compatibility
   A consultant should respect your church’s mission, theology, and culture. If the relationship does not feel like a fit, the partnership will struggle.
3. Understand Their Approach
   Some consultants are highly hands-on, while others act more as advisors. Clarify expectations before signing a contract.
4. Evaluate Cost vs. Value
   Hiring a consultant is an investment, but it often results in far greater returns. Open Philanthropy highlights how strategic giving can multiply impact far beyond the initial investment.
5. Ensure Transparency
   Reputable consultants will be clear about fees, deliverables, and timelines. Initiatives like Philanthropy Together show how collaboration and openness build trust in giving communities.

---

The Role of Technology in Campaigns

While consultants provide expertise, churches also need the right tools to maximize success. This is where Giveable plays a powerful role. Unlike simple donation processors, Giveable is a comprehensive fundraising platform designed for churches.

Benefits include:

• Year-Round Engagement: Keep members connected through mobile giving, online tools, and personalized communication.
• Clear Impact Storytelling: Share updates and testimonies so givers see how their generosity shapes ministry.
• Recurring Giving Options: Stabilize income by encouraging automated gifts.
• Campaign Tracking and Insights: Monitor progress in real time to adjust strategies as needed.
• Transparency: Build trust with members by showing exactly how funds are used.

Pairing a consultant’s strategic guidance with Giveable’s technology creates a powerful combination. Leaders gain both expert direction and digital tools, making it easier to inspire confidence and sustain long-term generosity.

---

A Few More Valuable Insights

Major capital campaigns require vision, planning, and the right support. While some churches may manage on their own, many benefit greatly from bringing in a consultant to guide strategy, train leaders, and build confidence. Paired with a platform like Giveable, churches can move from simply asking for donations to running effective, transparent, and inspiring fundraising campaigns.

If your church is preparing for a major capital campaign, consider whether outside guidance and better fundraising tools could help you achieve more than you imagined.